A lower advertised loan rate is not enough to establish savings. Compare the actual offer, net proceeds and total repayment against a realistic card-payoff plan.
Start with the debt being replaced
List each balance, rate, minimum and promotional expiry. Use the payment you can sustain, not a national average. Ask whether a quote uses a soft inquiry or requires a hard credit check; prequalification is not approval or final pricing.
Run a consistent comparison
For a hypothetical $20,000 balance amortized over 36 months with monthly interest, 22% APR produces a payment of about $763.81. At 14%, the payment is about $683.55. With no fees or new charges, the total-payment difference is about $2,889.23.
Use unrounded payments when comparing totals; actual daily-interest contracts and rounding can differ. A longer term can lower the payment while raising total cost. There is no universal four- or five-percentage-point spread that guarantees a worthwhile refinance.
Check proceeds and the behavior after closing
A 5% fee deducted from a $20,000 loan leaves $19,000 for creditors, not $20,000. A larger gross loan may be needed, changing both payment and cost. Read the disclosed APR, finance charge, amount financed and any collateral requirements.
Confirm the old accounts were paid, continue required payments until confirmed, and plan how to prevent new balances. Consolidation changes the creditor and terms; it does not reduce principal simply by combining bills. If the proposed payment is unaffordable, ask creditors or a reputable nonprofit counselor about alternatives.
Sources and review date
CFPB: Consolidating credit-card debt
Primary sources checked November 9, 2026. Dollar examples are hypothetical unless stated otherwise.
Choose consolidation only after the complete offer improves an affordable repayment plan. Keep the comparison and verify the payoff transfers rather than relying on the headline rate.




