Consolidation changes how a debt is financed; it does not erase the balance or solve a recurring budget shortfall. Moving card debt to a home equity line of credit also adds a direct claim against the home. Compare the actual offers and a realistic repayment plan before choosing the lowest advertised rate.
Compare the same principal and payoff term
For a hypothetical $20,000 balance repaid over 60 equal monthly payments, a constant annual interest rate of 8% produces about $405.53 per month and $4,331.67 in interest. At 12.4%, the figures are $448.94 and $6,936.53. At 22%, they are $552.38 and $13,142.69.
These calculations use the annual rate divided by twelve, no new borrowing and no fees; interest totals use unrounded payments. They are not current average rates or quotes. Holding the term constant avoids making a longer repayment schedule look cheaper merely because its monthly payment is smaller.
Stress-test the HELOC contract
The CFPB describes HELOCs as borrowing repeatedly against home equity, with risk of losing the home if repayment fails. Rates are usually variable. The payment can also rise when the draw period ends and repayment begins.
The 8% scenario above assumes a constant rate and voluntary five-year amortization. It is not a promise that a HELOC’s required draw-period minimum will retire the debt in five years. Ask for the index, margin, adjustment limits, repayment schedule, fees and any fixed-rate conversion terms.
Verify the personal-loan alternative
Check whether the specific offer is fixed-rate and unsecured; those features should not be assumed from the words personal loan. Compare APR, fees, amount actually disbursed and total scheduled payments.
If a hypothetical $20,000 loan has a 5% origination fee deducted from proceeds, you receive $19,000, leaving $1,000 of card debt uncovered unless funded elsewhere. Financing the fee changes the principal and the comparison. Use enough net proceeds to resolve the intended balances without counting the same money twice.
Calculate the promotional payoff separately
A hypothetical $20,000 balance transfer with a 4% fee creates $20,800 to repay if the fee is added to the balance. At a genuine 0% rate for twenty full monthly payments, paying $1,040 a month clears it by the end, assuming no other charges.
Confirm transfer eligibility and credit limit, promotional dates, payment requirements and the later APR. New purchases can have different interest treatment. The promotion is not nearly free if the needed payment does not fit or a substantial balance remains after it ends.
Fix the budget alongside the financing
List all obligations after the move, including any cards not fully paid off. Decide how you will avoid rebuilding the card balances while repaying the new debt. Lowering the rate cannot cure spending that persistently exceeds available income.
Compare continuing repayment, asking issuers about assistance and qualified nonprofit credit counseling as well as new borrowing. Unsecured debt is not free of legal consequences, but pledging home equity creates a specific collateral risk that deserves separate weight.
Sources and review date
CFPB: HELOC draw period, repayment and collateral
CFPB: Debt consolidation options and costs
Primary sources checked November 9, 2026. Dollar examples are hypothetical unless stated otherwise.
Choose using the full repayment cost, required cash flow and consequences if payments fail. A HELOC can be cheaper under some assumptions, but the rate, fees and collateral can change that result. Consolidation is useful only when the complete plan remains affordable after the balances move.




