Mortgage guide

FHA's 2027 Credit Score Rule: When Lenders Submit Two Models, the Lower Score Counts

Starting with FHA case numbers assigned on or after January 1, 2027, lenders can use Classic FICO, FICO 10T or VantageScore 4.0 — but if they submit more than one, HUD's October 8 rule says the lowest selected score decides your eligibility.

FHA's 2027 Credit Score Rule: When Lenders Submit Two Models, the Lower Score Counts
Educational content only. This article is for general informational purposes and does not constitute financial, tax, or legal advice. Results and strategies may vary based on individual circumstances. Consult a qualified professional before making financial decisions.

FHA loans are about to accept two newer credit score models, VantageScore 4.0 and FICO 10T, alongside the Classic FICO they have always used. The catch is in the math: under Mortgagee Letter 2026-11, issued by HUD on October 8, 2026, a lender that submits more than one model must use the lowest of the selected scores, and that number determines the credit-score financing tier, alongside the other underwriting requirements.

What HUD actually changed

The letter rewrites how FHA calculates the Minimum Decision Credit Score (MDCS), the one number that sets your maximum loan-to-value (LTV). It applies to all FHA-insured Title II single-family programs and takes effect for case numbers assigned on or after January 1, 2027. Loans with case numbers assigned before then follow the existing rules.

HUD says the newer models use trended data, meaning how your balances and payments move over time, and can draw on non-traditional credit such as rent and utility payments. HUD also states that FHA will keep requiring a tri-merge credit report (scores from all three bureaus) and that the minimum score thresholds stay the same no matter which model is used.

How the new score math works, step by step

  • Step 1 — Pick a score for each model. For every model the lender submits, look at the scores from the three bureaus: if there are three different scores, use the middle one; if two scores differ, use the lower one; if there is only one score, use that.
  • Step 2 — Pick your borrower-level score. If the lender submitted more than one model, your borrower-level score is the lowest of the per-model scores. With one model, it is simply that model's score.
  • Step 3 — Pick the loan's score. The MDCS is the lowest borrower-level score among everyone on the loan. Borrowers with no scores (insufficient or non-traditional credit) are left out of that comparison.
  • Step 4 — Apply the thresholds. An MDCS of 580 or higher is eligible for maximum financing. An MDCS from 500 to 579 is limited to 90% LTV. A reported MDCS below 500 is not eligible for FHA insurance. Applicants without traditional scores follow separate manual-underwriting requirements rather than being assigned a zero score. Certain transaction types, including HECMs, have different treatment.
  • Same models for everyone: the lender must use the same model or models for every borrower. It cannot, for example, submit FICO 10T for one spouse and VantageScore 4.0 for the other.

A worked example: same couple, different results

Here is a hypothetical couple. The bureau scores below are made up to show how the rule works; they are not real or typical scores.

Borrower A has hypothetical Classic FICO scores of 612, 618 and 625 (middle: 618) and VantageScore 4.0 scores of 590, 601 and 604 (middle: 601). Borrower B has Classic FICO scores of 575, 583 and 590 (middle: 583) and VantageScore 4.0 scores of 571, 579 and 588 (middle: 579). All three scores within each set differ, so the middle-score step is unambiguous.

If the lender submits Classic FICO only, the borrower-level scores are 618 and 583, so the MDCS is 583, which qualifies for maximum financing. If the lender submits Classic FICO and VantageScore 4.0, the borrower-level scores drop to 601 and 579, so the MDCS is 579, which caps the loan at 90% LTV. The credit files are the same in both cases. Only the set of models submitted changed.

What landing below 580 costs at closing

FHA's Single Family Handbook caps purchase loans at 96.5% of the adjusted value, the familiar 3.5% minimum down payment. Assume a $350,000 home with the adjusted value equal to the price. At 96.5% LTV, the base loan is $337,750 and the down payment is $12,250. At 90% LTV, the base loan is $315,000 and the down payment is $35,000, which means $22,750 more cash needed at closing.

To isolate the loan-size effect, assume a hypothetical 7.40% note rate for a 30-year fixed loan, not a current FHA quote or APR. Principal and interest are $2,338.51 on $337,750 and $2,181.00 on $315,000. FHA upfront and annual mortgage insurance, taxes, homeowners insurance, closing charges and any financed fees are excluded. An actual FHA base loan, total financed balance and payment must include applicable program charges.

Who could gain, and who should be careful

For a borrower with the same reported score sets, taking the lowest selected model score means adding another model cannot raise the resulting borrower-level score. A different model used alone may produce a different result. Do not assume that rent or utility history will appear in your file or improve your score; ask the lender which data and models are actually available.

The risk is for borrowers close to 580. If one model puts you just above the line and another puts you just below it, which models your lender submits can decide whether you put down 3.5% or 10%. HUD's letter does not say which model or models a lender has to choose, so expect practices to differ from lender to lender.

What to do before you apply for an FHA loan in 2027

  • Ask each lender which credit score model or models it plans to submit to FHA's TOTAL scorecard for case numbers assigned on or after January 1, 2027.
  • If you are near 580, ask for your scores under each model the lender can pull and work through the middle-score and lowest-score steps above with a co-borrower's scores included.
  • Remember that the lowest borrower sets the loan's score. If a co-borrower's score is what keeps you under 580, compare the score math with and without that person, keeping in mind that dropping a co-borrower also removes their income from qualifying.
  • Pay down revolving balances and avoid new credit inquiries in the months before you apply. Those steps generally help under all three models.
  • Check the timing. The new method applies based on when your FHA case number is assigned, not your closing date, so a case number assigned in December 2026 falls under the current rules.

Limits worth knowing

Sources

✦ The takeaway

FHA's move to newer score models could help some renters and steady payers, but the lowest-score rule means more models do not mean a better result. If you plan to apply for an FHA loan after January 1, 2027, ask which models your lender submits, check every borrower's score against the 580 line, and price out the 3.5% and 10% down payments before you make an offer. You can test both down payments in LoanPal's Down Payment Calculator. This article is general information, not personalized financial advice.